Cans vs. Buckets

When storing long term food storage items such as flour, beans, rice, wheat, sugar, etc. it’s important to know which containers are best for your personal food storage situation as well as how best to store them in those containers.  Here, we will discuss plastic food grade buckets and metal #10 cans, the most common containers in which to store these foods.

First, let me explain the need for oxygen absorbers in these containers as the following post discusses including them in your cans and/or buckets.

Oxygen Absorbers


 
Oxygen absorbers, sometimes called “oxygen packets” or “oxy packs”, are the little plastic pouches you will often find in commercial foods like beef jerky.  They are used to remove oxygen from the airtight container they are placed in.

It is very common for bags of grains and legumes to come with eggs of insects lying dormant inside.  Paper bags are especially susceptible to harboring these insects and allowing rodents access to their contents (thus the need for more stable containers like cans and buckets). 

Many people believe that the insects will “get inside” their container.  In actuality, you are bringing in the eggs of these unwanted guests in the product you are storing.

The oxygen absorbers remove the oxygen from your container, making it impossible for those eggs to hatch and begin eating and nesting in your bucket.  Essentially, without oxygen, the eggs die.

As we continue this discussion, remember that the whole goal is to remove all possible oxygen to increase the life of your long term storage items.

*Note:  The only exception to this rule is when storing sugar:

NEVER put oxy packs in any container with sugar.  Without oxygen, sugar molecules adhere to each other which cause your sugar to harden into a block that is unusable. 

Insects don’t nest in sugar (because of its lack of nutrient content for their offspring…a lesson for us all!), so there is no need for oxygen absorbers anyway.

How many oxy packs should you use in a container? 


According to Honeyville Farms, a distributor of grains and other products for long term food storage, “With 100cc oxygen absorbers, you use about 2 per gallon when storing grains, flours or rice.  You use about 4 per gallon when storing pasta and beans.  Why, you ask?  Well, grains, flours and rice are more dense so there is less oxygen to absorb…while pasta and beans are less dense which means there is more oxygen to absorb.”

Where can you obtain oxygen absorbers?


Oxygen absorbers are available at any Church cannery.  They come in a large, sealed plastic bag to keep them from being “used up” by absorbing outside oxygen. 

They cost $.10/oxy pack at the cannery.

You can also order them from Honeyville Farms with different sizes for different costs.  Click here to access their oxy packs ordering page.

How do you store oxygen absorbers?


They can be stored in the bag they originally came in, if going to be used in a reasonable period of time.  When taking out the oxy packs to include in your can or bucket, seal their storage bag back up immediately so they don’t absorb any oxygen but the oxygen in your container!

They can also be stored in a glass jar or other airtight container.

 

Plastic Buckets


 


Plastic, food grade buckets are a common way to store large amounts of product at one time.  They can be obtained at most local grocery stores during case lot sales, during seasonal sales at Wal-Mart, or anytime at Emergency Essentials in Orem.   Prices vary widely, but you can expect to pay between $5-$7 for one bucket.  However, sales have brought those prices down to $4 at times.

These buckets usually hold about 5 gallons of product so they are referred to as “five gallon buckets”.  They have a handle and come with a lid that, once secured, is very difficult to take off.  You’ll need a bucket wrench or lid lifter to be able to lift the lid once it is secured, which costs approximately $2.
 

I have two of these bucket openers, one with my food storage and one in my kitchen.  It’s always better to have more than one….just in case.

Plastic is a breathable material, therefore you will need to line your bucket with a mylar  (or “metallized”) bag, also available at Emergency Essentials for about $1.75.
 

You must also include oxy packs in your bucket.  Refer above to know how many to include, depending on what product you are storing.

Though buckets can easily be stacked and do not require shelving, do not place plastic buckets directly on a cement floor as chemicals can leech into the bucket over time.  Placing cardboard or wood underneath creates an efficient barrier.

Note:  There are other options to obtaining buckets.  One such is Payson Fruit Growers who get rid of buckets every year for very little to no cost.  They are, however, much smaller at 3-4 gallons.

Approximate Cost breakdown for 5-gallon buckets

  • Bucket itself: $6 (available for less)
  • Mylar bag: $1.75
  • Bucket wrench/lid lifter: $2
  • Oxygen packets approximately $1.00
  • Total approximate cost for storing 5 gallons of food:  $10.75

Pros and cons of five gallon buckets


Pros:

  • Large amounts of product can be stored in a single container. 
  • Useful when buying in bulk…dump and you’re done
  • Gamma lids can be attached for easy access to food while keeping it airtight
  • Don’t require a canner device to seal it shut, can be sealed with a mallet by hand
  • Can use the bucket to store your product while you are using it
  • Great for large families who need to store AND use large amounts at the same time
  • Reusable:  Buckets can be reused once opened, though a new lid will need to be obtained or a Gamma lid attached.
  • Because the lids are formed to allow it, stacking of buckets is very easy so shelves are not necessary.  However, buckets should never be put directly on concrete, so make sure to put wood or cardboard between the bucket and a cement floor.
  • Great for storing large amounts of food, rodent and moisture free, for very long periods of time.

Cons:

  • HEAVY!  No matter what you store in the buckets, because they hold so much product they are very heavy and difficult to move around.
  • Difficult to open, even with a bucket wrench. 
  • Because of the two above issues, elderly or physically challenged individuals will usually need help with these containers.  This needs to be considered when deciding on a storage method.
  • A mylar bag is needed which increases the cost of storing in a bucket.

 

#10 Cans


 

#10 cans are the cans you are used to seeing with food storage products.  They hold about a gallon of product and do not require any additions to be food-storage-ready except oxygen packets.  See above to know how many packets would be required for the food you are storing.

Plastic lids are available at the cannery to allow you to keep your food airtight after opening the can.  Commercial cans (those filled with food that are sold in stores) come with their own plastic lid. 

Empty #10 cans are only available at the cannery and require a canner for sealing.  Here are the cost breakdowns from the cannery price list for each item needed:
  • #10 dry pack can: $.75
  • #10 metal lid for sealing can:  $.15
  • #10 plastic lid $.10 (when storing several #10 cans of the same product, you only need one plastic lid for the whole group since you will likely have only one can open at a time).
  • $.10 per oxygen packet needed
  • Labels for your cans are available upon request, no charge

Cost breakdown for #10 cans


So, depending on the number of oxygen packets needed, the cost of storing one gallon of food in a #10 can is approximately $1.20, minus the cost of the food you are storing.

In comparison, then, a bucket (if obtained at $6) would require about $2.15/gallon and a can requires $1.20/gallon.  This cost comparison could vary greatly depending on the cost of your bucket, so look for sales!

Pros and Cons of #10 cans


Pros

  • Small, lightweight and easy to carry in an evacuation.
  • Completely rodent-proof
  • Air and water tight
  • Easily opened with a can opener
  • Good for small families who don’t go through a lot of food at one time

Cons

  • Not reusable
  • Not as efficient for storing large amounts of food
  • Do not stack well by themselves
  • Shelves and boxes are needed to store many cans, increasing the eventual cost
  • A special canner is needed to seal the cans, so it must be done at the cannery or at our Genola satellite cannery at the home of the Garners.
  • Larger families will go through the cans much faster than buckets


How to choose a method


Depending on your personal needs and situation, it may be easy to choose a storage method.  If you are living alone, there would rarely be a need to deal with the large, heavy buckets when you don’t need to store as much as a large family.

But, if you see that there are benefits to each storage container and have a lot of food to store, you can do what we did…do both.

I think in terms of how to prepare for as many scenarios as possible.  It’s important to me to be able to take food in an evacuation so I have grains and beans in cans because I can carry them easily.  However, because we have such a large family, we have lots and lots of buckets, too…and teenage boys to carry them around!  J

No comments:

Post a Comment